Best Organic Eyeliners Reviews & Buying Guide in 2021

best organic eyeliner

Eyeliner is an important part of makeup, especially for eye makeup. To create a dramatic eye look it’s been used from very ancient times and nowadays eyeliner is an essential item of the everyday makeup routine. As your eyes are the most sensitive area of your entire body so, choosing the best quality eyeliner is a must.

Organic eyeliners will offer you vibrant colors and smooth texture from all-natural resources like herbs, real fruits, and plant oils that are suitable for all kinds of skin and safe for daily use. It will not only give you a stunning look but also will nourish the delicate skin of your eye area.

Finding the perfect one for you can be confusing and hard as well. But, don’t worry, we are here to help you. Our team tested a bunch of organic eyeliners, did several hours of research on the ingredients, texture, customer reviews, and then selected the best organic eyeliners.

In our article, we will give you a detailed review of these best organic eyeliners with a buying guide and faq session to disclose all your confusion.

Relevant article

10 Best Remington Hair Straighteners Reviews & Guide [2021]
Best After Tanning Lotion in 2021 [Updated Reviews]
Best Blue Black Hair Dye for Dark Hair in 2021

Image Product Rating Price
Avril Certified Organic Eye Liner Pencil
Juice Beauty Phyto-pigments Liquid Line
100% PURE Long Last Liquid Eye Liner
Honeybee Gardens Effortless Eye Liner
Zuzu Luxe Liquid Eyeliner

Table of Contents

Best Organic Eyeliners Reviews 2021

1. Avril Certified Organic Eye Liner Pencil


This Avro Organic Eyeliner Pencil is one of the best and trusted organic eyeliner brand that doesn’t contain phenoxyethanol, parabens, or potassium sorbate. Moreover, it is certified organic by ECOCERT Greenlife and all the ingredients are using here are 100% natural and 24% are produced by organic farming.

This is a durable eyeliner pencil that you can have it all day long and also it is smudge-free. The eyeliner ensures the perfect cover of your eyes with a delicate application and creates an attractive look and mind-blowing eye make up.

Along with this, there are too many colors that are available that you can choose from like-  black, white, blue, brown, greens, metallics, gray, rose gold, etc.

  • Not tested on animals
  • Available in many colors
  • Easy to take off
  • Some users can get irritation if has too much sensitive skin

2. Juice Beauty Phyto-pigments Liquid Line

Juice Beauty

Juicy beauty is a liquid eyeliner that made from all certified organic ingredients and plant-derived phyto-pigments with durable and smudge-proof formula. The eyeliner will give you a dramatic eye look with it’s easy to use tip by which you can draw your favorite line smoothly according to your choice-thick or thin.

The combination of olive oil and aloe vera juice in it makes it great to use on sensitive skin. The product is free from carbon black, coal tar and synthetic dyes and the blend of garlic, daisy, basil, coriander, and cranberry make the substitute for artificial colors and these produce a rich color that makes this intense black liquid gel more acceptable to use.

  • Convenient to use for most sensitive skin
  • Has easy to use tip
  • Artificial dyes and synthetic scent-free
  • Takes time to dry

3. 100% PURE Long Last Liquid Eye Liner

If you want an eyeliner that works incredibly for staying all day just the way you want to keep it, this 100% pure eyeliner is the best option for you.

It is a natural pure eyeliner that is highly pigmented and water-resistant so it won’t drip and smudge. The interesting thing about this eyeliner is that the manufacturers don’t use synthetic colors, they use black tea powder and cocoa to provide sleek and the richest black color.

It has a superfine tip that makes you able to do any ultrafine line to make a crazy eye look. The lines of the eyeliner won’t crack or flake off as it is moist with aloe vera and vegetable glycerin that soothes and moisturizes the area all day and night. This eyeliner will give you the most precise look just like you want.

  • Has ultra fine tip
  • Brush is long and soft
  • Fruit pigmented ingredients
  • No cons found

4. Honeybee Gardens Effortless Eye Liner

Honeybee Gardens Eye Liner

Honeybee Gardens is one of the most reputed and trusted brands for skincare and beauty products. This eyeliner is actually a traditional eyeliner with all-natural and organic ingredients. It is gluten-free, paraben-free and this vegan eyeliner will blow your mind with several natural and beautiful colors.

It is easy to apply eyeliner that won’t pull or drags your skin and you can apply smooth line very gently. You will get the gorgeous long waring look with a buttery and good pigmentation. Moreover, the creamy and pleasant texture is easy to remove and will make you buy it again.

  • Good pigmentation
  • Buttery and smooth touch
  • Easy to remove
  • Not that good for waterline

5. Zuzu Luxe Liquid Eyeliner

Zuzu Luxe

This is the quickest drying eyeliner among the best organic eyeliners on our list. The eyeliner has a fine calligraphy tip with water resistance and gluten-free formula that lets you draw the thinnest line and shape according to your mood and make the classy eye look with ultimate precision to line. It is a little bit slippery texture as it contains jojoba oil for smooth application and the oily texture hydrates the area of application.

The key ingredients are aloe, bentonite clay, jojoba, eyebright, and organic minerals. The rich creamy color is super dim that defines your attractive eye. Moreover, the eyeliner has 8 colors and 4 of them are shimmery like pink, blue, orange, and green. So, this can be your ultimate choice.

  • Quick drying formula
  • Comes with fine calligraphy tip
  • Keeps the skin around the eyes hydrated.
  • Expensive than others

6. PuroBIO Certified ORGANIC Extra Black Eyeliner

PuroBIO Certified

You will fall in love with this extra black and highly pigmented eyeliner that will take your eye look to the next level.

This amazing eyeliner has a rich creamy color that gives your eyelash line a perfect blend with a smooth texture. It has a smudge-free formula and it’s proven that it won’t drip or smudge for almost 8 hours.

It contains all the healthy and natural ingredients vitamin E, avocado, olive oil, jojoba oil, coconut oil, baobab oil, and also free from formaldehyde, mineral oil, parabens, sulfates SLS and SLES, formaldehyde-releasing brokers.

So, there is no doubt that this eyeliner is highly recommended for sensitive skin. Moreover, you can use this eyeliner as a kajal also.

  • High quality natural and organic ingredients
  • Affordable price
  • Can also use as a kajal
  • Not stays for long time

7. Burt’s Bees Nourishing Eyeliner

Burt's Bees

This comes with three exceptional stunning colors-Midnight Gray, Soft Black and Warm Brown. It is safe and easy to apply and also blend so smoothly. Moreover, it won’t pull over to the eyelid so you can create your favorite eye look easily.

The texture of the eyeliner is soft as it is made with 99.9% organic ingredients like mango and responsibly sourced meadowfoam seed, jojoba oil which not only gives a perfect and buttery blend, they nourish the skin as well. Along with these, this eyeliner is free from phthalates, parabens, SLS, synthetic fragrances, petrolatum, and silicones. So, you can pick this organic eyeliner for you.

  • Safe for contact lens wearer
  • Vegan friendly
  • Easy to apply
  • Won’t last for long day

8. Pacifica Natural Eye Pencil

Pacifica Natural Eye Pencil

If you are searching for an eyeliner that has organic ingredients with beneficial effects, you can choose this eyeliner. It is made with Shea Butter, Jojoba oil, Vitamin C and Vitamin E, this rich nourishing ingredients hydrates and nourishes the skin of the eye area and the soft buttery texture provides a stunning look.

The high nourishing properties won’t irritate your skin and the eyeliner is also easy to apply and remove as well. This is available in three different colors like-Jet (Black), Gun Metal (Silver/Gray), Fringe (Brown). The water and smudge resistance formula and long-lasting mineral color keep your dramatic eye look for all day.

  • Can be used as eyebrows also
  • Waterproof formula
  • No toxic ingredients
  • No cons found

9. HAUS laboratories by Lady Gaga: Liquid eyeliner

HAUS Eyeliner

It is the last organic eyeliner on our list, if you are a gaga fan, you can go for this eyeliner without any hesitation. The color blend is so amazing and the density of the liquid provides an even blend to your variant eye look. The flexible felt tip and quick dry formula make the use of eyeliner easier.

This liquid eyeliner glides so smoothly without pulling and tugging in the eyes so you can create your gorgeous eye look just as you want.

The citric acid, castor oil, and coco-glucoside in it make the texture glassy that helps to create a fine line shape. The eyeliner can be the ultimate choice for a lady gaga lover.

  • Cruelty free and vegan
  • Long lasting wear
  • Flexible to create thick and thin lines
  • BHT is used here

Buying Guide

Choosing an organic eyeliner is not an easy task, you have to check many things that help to choose the best one in the market. So here we are including an in-depth buying guide that will refine your purchasing decision.

Things to Consider while Choosing an Organic Eyeliner

Reputed Brand

Eyes are the most sensitive and delicate area of your entire body, so before using any product, you should always take a concern about the brand of the item. Reputed branded organic eyeliners are more acceptable to use as they use 100% natural and organic ingredients, free from all toxic and synthetic chemicals, artificial colors or scents etc that won’t cause you any kind i sensitivity or allergic reactions

Natural Ingredients

Best organic eyeliners contain all the natural and organic ingredients that not only creates the creamy and smooth texture, but also hydrates and nourishes your delicate skin around your eyes. Plant oils, extracts of fruits, herbs and natural antibacterial and nourishing properties are used here. All ingredients here are eco friendly and vegan which are great for most sensitive skins to use.

Pencil vs Liquid Eyeliners

You may face a little bit of confusion about what form of eyeliner to choose- liquid or pencil. We will say that it depends on what kind of looks you want to create first.

If you want to create a clean flick look, you can pick the liquid one with a flexible tip for easy application.

On the other hand for a stubble look, a soft pencil eyeliner with a light color will just do the work. That means pencil eyeliners are suitable for a simple makeup look

Application of liquid eyeliners need a lot of patience and practice to be perfect and pencil liners are just simple to apply.

Chemicals Used in Non-Organic Eyeliners

Now you have an idea what type of ingredients are used in organic eyeliners. But, you should have a clear concept about the ingredients of nonorganic eyeliners that are harmful for skin.

BAK, BHT, BHA – Benzalkonium Chloride and Butylated Compounds(BHT, BHA) are chemical ingredients that can lead to the hormonal disruption and disturbs the healthy functioning of your eyes.

Carbon Black- it is used to create black pigmented color but it is a cancer causing agent and can cause organ toxicity.

Paraben- we have talked so many times about this component in our article because it is the most widely used item on makeup and beauty products. But, it’s a harmful item. It can cause skin irritation,hormonal disruption, contact dermatitis, skin aging, and rosacea.

Ethanolamine Compounds– The Ethanolamine Compounds include DEA, TEA and/or MEA that can lead to breast cancer.

There are more other artificial or chemical ingredients that are used in non organic eyeliners like heavy metal, p-Phenylenediamine, Prime Yellow Carnauba Wax, Retinyl Acetate etc. try to avoid eyeliners along with other makeup or beauty care products that contain these kind components.

How to use eyeliners

Liquid eyeliners

You can put a little bit of primer to the eyelid as that will help to stick the eyeliner to your lid the whole day. Also, the most important thing is you should have a steady position to avoid the risk of wavy line or uneven application. Draw some dot or dashed to the lashline, that will help you to draw the line evenly. Connect the dash or dots slowly. Finally add a small tail to the outer edge of your eyelid, that’s how you can make the perfect wing.

Pencil eyeliners

Apply pencil eyeliner to the upper lid

At first place the eyeliner close to your lash line and then draw from the outer corner to the inner corner of the line. Keep the line thinner, then make it thick according to your makeup look. If you are not a pro applicator then you can make dots or dashes on the lash line and then just connect them

Apply pencil eyeliner to lower lid

The lower lid of eyes are softer than the upper lid so you have to be careful while applying here. Avoid the rims of your eyes, place the eyeliner close to the lashline and then softly draw from outer part to inner part. This line should be thinner than upper lid line otherwise you may look harsh. 

Finally, connect the upper line and lower line on the outside corner of your eyes.


If you are concerned about the health of your skin and want to become eco friendly, organic items are the great alternatives for this. The best organic eyeliners contain all the qualities of nourishing, hydrating and antibacterial properties with the goodness of all natural resources that keep your skin healthy. We picked these organic articles in our article from the trusted and reputed brands and all are top rated from customer reviews. We hope our article will be helpful for you to find out your perfect organic eyeliner.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This
Scroll to Top